Sep 12, Vikas Datta rated it it was amazing. An incisive introduction to an ideology much discredited wrongly or rightly but one, i predict, the world hasn't seen the last of Holmes' introduction to communism is one that was straightforward, easy to read and understand, and concise. Going from the rise of Communism to the ideology of communism and the eventual problems inherent in the Communist Systems, Holmes' walkthrough of the Communist systems from the rise to the fall of, most notably, the USSR, has increased my understanding of, perhaps, the most controversial economic and political system in the world thus far.
Nov 19, Josh rated it really liked it. Like the other Very Short Introduction books, it packs a good introduction into a short book. I learned a decent broad outline of the history of communism in the 20th century. It gives a decent level of detail about the major players Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Mao I couldn't expect a great deal more in less than pages, so a good book for someone without much knowledge of communism but is interested in gaining a foundation for study of Communism.
Jan 30, Kevin Frint rated it liked it. Also didn't really elaborate about different sub-sects of communist thought, simply explaining the general premise of communism. Jan 22, Shelley Alongi rated it really liked it. This is a good introduction with a pretty thorough overview of the history of communism in the 20th century. I found it interesting and I did learn something although I have read quite a bit about it. I would recommend it. May 09, EvilRoySlade69 rated it really liked it. Mar 27, Jacob Hawk rated it it was amazing.
A concise, accessible history of the practice of communism with just enough theory to understand its practice. I would enjoy reading a history of the theory of communism by Holmes. Communism is an ideological and economic system that dominated vast regions of the World during the twentieth century.
At its peak, almost a third of the World population lived under communist regimes. Even today 1. It is inconceivable to study the modern history without understanding communism in all of its manifestations. It would be impossible in a single book, especially one that is Communism is an ideological and economic system that dominated vast regions of the World during the twentieth century.
- A Feather of Stone (Balefire Series #3).
- Launch a WordPress.com Blog In A Day For Dummies!
- Short-Sale Pre-Foreclosure Investing: How to Buy No-Equity Properties Directly from the Bank -- at Huge Discounts!
- The Possibility of Language: A discussion of the nature of language, with implications for human and machine translation.
- Communism: A Very Short Introduction by Leslie Holmes?
It would be impossible in a single book, especially one that is a very short introduction, to do full justice to such a complex and vast subject. Keeping that in mind, this book manages to encompass quite a bit of basic information on communist regimes and societies.
Marx and Communism: A Very Short Introduction
All of the most salient characteristics are well documented, with very insightful observations about the differences among various communist countries, or within single country over its history. However, there are some glaring omissions. The role of the vast internal security apparatus and the extent of politically motivated imprisonment and state torture are mentioned just in passing.
This is quite an unacceptable omission, since it is precisely thorough state coercion and force that communist regimes solidified and preserved their power. Indeed, there has not been a single communist country that had become communist without the use of violence. Even more glaring than the omissions of the above nature are the analysis errors that permeate this book.
The author repeats the old canard that communism is different from "true" Marxism, and that Marx and Engels probably would not have approved of how their ides were implemented. This completely sidesteps the issue of why was it necessary to implement communism in such a brutal way to begin with.
What books introduce communism? - Quora
In fact, Marx's ideology was so far removed from reality that the only way it could ever be implemented was in situations where normal operations of market economy were nonexistent to begin with. Another rather annoying point that the author brings up on several occasion is his apparent gloating over the recent economic crisis that has affected much of the world economy.
To him this is somehow a proof that the market economy is also not all that is cranked up to be, so maybe we need to take a second look at some of the communist policies after all. Besides being incredibly shortsighted, this view has the effect of partially rehabilitating political systems that had brought so much devastation and misery to literally billions of people. It is hard to imagine that someone would be making similar statements about, say, fascism.
Yes, according to that viewpoint, fascism was an evil regime, but at least in fascist countries trains ran on time. It is unfortunate that communism never quite got the stigma that it deserves, and this short book will not make any steps in that direction. Aug 24, C M rated it really liked it Shelves: communism , eastern-europe , political-theory. Leslie Holmes did an excellent job in summarizing the core of communism in theory and practice for a broad audience.
Perhaps some will be disappointed by the limited discussion of the theory of communism, which is only central in the first chapter, but it gets the main ideas across, particularly for understanding communism in practice. The next chapters summarize the history of communist regimes, the political and economic systems, social policies, international allegiances, and the collapse of Leslie Holmes did an excellent job in summarizing the core of communism in theory and practice for a broad audience.
The next chapters summarize the history of communist regimes, the political and economic systems, social policies, international allegiances, and the collapse of communism. It is all at a very basic level, which means that I learned very little from the book -- I am a political scientist who studies contemporary extremist movements, mostly of the right, with some academic knowledge on the topic, but definitely not an academic expert.
Hence, I don't see much value in the book for scholars, but it is great for students and interested laypersons. My only critique is with the strong focus on China as a remaining communist regimes, while admitting the hybrid with capitalism. Holmes could at least have addressed in what way s China is still communist, distinguishing, perhaps, party and state.
Also, the last pages on the future of communism are of little value, given the lack of solid empirical and theoretical argumentation -- it seems mostly wishful thinking about a return to social democracy of the s. This doesn't take away from the fact that this is a great "very short introduction to communism. A slim and very high-level overview, as suggested by the title.
In its defense, though, the print is quite small. The author clearly wants to make the point that Communism as practiced in the 20th century is flawed in almost every way.
Even when possible benefits could be discussed, he's clear to point out that the West did it the same way or better. However, through his intro to Marxist thought and via comments made in various portions of the book, Holmes also emphasizes his opinion that the A slim and very high-level overview, as suggested by the title. However, through his intro to Marxist thought and via comments made in various portions of the book, Holmes also emphasizes his opinion that the "Communism" of Lenin, Stalin, and Mao is not the socialism envisioned by Marx and was in many ways doomed to failure.
I did come out of the book wanting to read more about Khrushchev, Mao, and Deng Xiaoping. Jul 11, Ikiryo rated it did not like it Shelves: politics , Where to start.
See a Problem?
First of all, misleading title as it is more an introduction to Marxist-Leninism. The author makes no mention of the utopian thinkers before Marx, who himself is introduced in only a couple of lines before we move over to Lenin where the supposed Grand History of Communism starts. The whole book felt biased and incoherent, trying to make a point by moving from country to country quickly with each paragraph just to point out the authors biased opinion on 'communism'. All together Where to start. All together a disappointing attempt to earn money off of a stigmatized ideology. Feb 20, Amitanshu Mishra rated it really liked it Shelves: While capitalism is one extreme, communism is the other.
I really liked the pace and the planned design of laying out a subject which can be utterly confusing at times. The words compel you to scrutinize the events that lead to the growth of communism. You tend to look at it more a radical force that was manipulated and was used means to personal ends.
The book is truly enlightening and gives every major episode its deserved space instead of cluttering everything. Jun 15, Berk Demir rated it did not like it.rikonn.biz/wp-content/2020-02-16/programmi-spia-per-pc.php
Marx and Communism: A Very Short Introduction
The book is full of non-objective, biased information on communism. I would not expect that from Oxford series, but all throughout the book, it only tells you how terrible is communism. Oxford Very Short Introduction serie should not do that, it should inform us, objectively. If the topic needs an argument, writer can include some of opposite one.
Mar 24, Alex Mechev rated it it was amazing. Good introduction into Communism; Both theory and practice. While the book focuses on the Soviet Union's history a little too much, it is level headed and often reminds the reader how disparate policies can be from the original philosophy. Jul 11, Titus Hjelm rated it liked it.
Shop by category
This is a quite light touch intro to historical communist regimes. Although the author makes his emphasis clear early on in the beginning, I would have preferred more theoretical reflection. In that sense the 'Socialism' volume in the VSI series is better. Jun 23, Jack rated it really liked it Shelves: nonfiction , politics. Jul 05, Lina Bina rated it really liked it. A nice and concise explanation of communism, encompassing history, the economic system, etc.
I enjoyed it and plan on reading more on the topic. What is communism? Where did the idea come from and what attracted people to it? Is there a future for communism? This Very Short Introduction considers these questions and more in the search to explore and understand this controversial political force. Explaining the theory behind its ideology, and examining the history and mindset behind its political, economic and social structures, Leslie Holmes considers the evolution of communism from Marx's time, to its practice in the Bolshevik Revolution, to its collapse in Holmes highlights the inner dynamics, crises, and demise of communism as a global system, and introduces the major players in the communist world, including Marx, Lenin, Stalin, and Mao.
When you visit a website, you are of course observable by the site itself, but you are also observable by third-party trackers that the site embeds in its code. You might be surprised to learn that the vast majority of websites include many of these third-party trackers. Websites includ Besides the obvious answers such as the communism manifesto. Capital is of course an essential reading but it is not advisable to jump right into.
I recommend finding companions online for Capital. In my opinion, the common suggestions like Capital and Communist Manifesto are either too long and complicated, or require the reader to be familiar with a lot of historical context. Two books that introduce communism from scratch, and are also easy to read are:.
- How women survived post-communism (and didn't laugh);
- Account Options;
- Communism: A Global history, – The Reluctant Internationalists ();
- Communism: a very short introduction;
- Reward Yourself.
- Communism: A Very Short Introduction - Leslie Holmes - Google книги?
- Funny Peculiar: Gershon Legman and the Psychopathology of Humor.